The Webtender
Forum and Chat

 Message 24024 of 39188 in General Discussion
 Share on Facebook |  Save to del.icio.us  
Subject: Re: martinis and manhattans - standard is shaken?
From: Dan the Melon Man
Posted: Fri Mar 10. 2006, 12:28 UTC
Followup to: "Re: martinis and manhattans - standard is shaken?"  by Natrone  (Thu Mar 9. 2006, 19:54 UTC)
> > So. I swirl because it has the devil-may-care nonchalance that a 
> > swirler deserves, while stirring just looks pansy.
> > 
> 
> That's one way to put it...
> 
> Another would be "That guy forgot where he put his bar spoon, or 
> worse, doesn't even have one behind the bar".  

Touche'
I won't deny there's sometimes an element of that :-B

Yes, I've worked dives where I brought in my own spoon. 
And yes, I'd rather have a bartender that realized one was useful (and a swirl 
was sufficient) rather than just giving up and building ... shaking (unlikely) 
... or (horrors) stick-blending.

> When I see a tender stirring I think that they know what 
> they're doing and that they're putting some attention and care into 
> my drink.

Mmm. 
And it's important whether they are going clockwise or anticlockwise, 
or whether the spoon is facing forward or back, 
and whether it has the right gradient of spiralled rifles on it.

I've heard each of these stories before, and (as in my post) came to the 
conclusion that it didn't make a damned bit of difference to the DRINK, so 
people that claim otherwise are full of **it.

>  Swirling looks lazy and unprepared, as though they hardly 
> ever make this drink and aren't sure what to do with it.

A possible observation, OK
but when (seldom) I do get the chance, I (personally) treat this with flair, 
always doing something else graceful (preparing garnish) with my other hand, 
possibly doing the swirl up in the air, a bit of break-dance shadow moves. A 
top spider-grip on the tin, etc. Not just a half-hearted half-shake.

>  I wouldn't 
> call stirring "pansy" - unless my pinky was sticking out as I moved 
> the spoon.  

Muddling can be macho, but I can't think of many decent stirs that are not in 
some way effette. 
But my background is party-bars and high-volume. If I was doing white-glove 
service, I'd have a different outlook, f'sure.

.dan.


 Current thread (47 messages):
 Message options:
 

Talk about drinks and bartending in The Webtender Forum.
Ask your questions, chat or share your best tricks with other visitors.

Home · Drink Recipes · Bookstore · Barstore · Handbook · Web Index · Feedback

Copyright © The Webtender.
About | Disclaimer | Privacy policy