The Webtender
Forum and Chat

 Message 19762 of 20656 in Recipe Exchange
 Share on Facebook |  Save to del.icio.us  
Subject: Re: Any cocktails where beer is used??
From: apetail
Posted: Sun Jul 19. 2009, 16:12 UTC
Followup to: "Any cocktails where beer is used??"  by giantcraig  (Sun Jul 19. 2009, 14:48 UTC)
> I am opening a microbrewery restaurant that will offer a full bar.  
> Can anyone think of a beer based cocktail??

There are not so many cocktails with beer in it but this may not have to be 
because beer would be a bad ingredient in mixed drinks. I believe it is, 
instead, because either bartenders like beer too much on its own or bartenders 
are not capable of making and promoting mixed drinks with beer.

If you have a bar selling many different types of beer I can only think of two 
strong reasons why you would also like to sell mixed drinks with beer. Either 
you want mixed drinks with beer just for the sake of having them (e.g. 
cocktail as a promotional/popular/fashion thing) or you want mixed drinks 
because mixing beer with something else actually makes it better.

If it is for the first reason than it doesn't really matter how you make your 
mixed drink as long as it will have a cocktailish image. You could think of 
substituting soda or other sparkling ingredients in many already existing 
mixed drinks. Classics like fizzes, mojito, french 75 (and many other 
champagne drinks) are easily remade using a proper microbrew as a substitute. 
Important ingredients would be things like a flute or martini glass, cocktail 
cherries or other fashionable garnishes, a cocktail shaker operated by a sexy 
guy or gal and something like umbrellas or such stupid things.

If it is for the second reason than you would have to generate for yourself, 
reasons why and how a beer and/or product range could be improved by mixing 
beer with other ingredients. One reason could be the mixing of ingredients 
increasing the differentiation in your product range. However this does not 
directly increase the value of a single product. 
As an owner of a microbrewery restaurant you know how to appreciate the work 
done by distillers, breweries and blenders. A beer or any other ingredient 
(e.g. malt whisky) is already an outstanding product. Bartenders, or 
mixologists, can at some times be too little careful with the flavours they 
work with. They may destroy the original intent of the composition of flavour 
of the products they work with (those products may already be a careful 
mixture of flavours and is more often than not destroyed or damaged). It is 
not strange to see a mixed drink (e.g. a cosmo) in which the original art 
(e.g. the well constructed composition of flavours in a citrus vodka) becomes 
destroyed by addition of several similar flavours (e.g. citrus liqueur, plus 
citrus juice, plus citrus oil).
Some people would work like: A beer has lemon notes, lets add a lemon flavour 
to emphasize this feature. This would damage the original composition. For 
instance, many brewers of wheat beer (which has lemon notes from coriander and 
citrus peels) express that adding a slice of lemon to the beer (which is often 
done in my area) is actually not the way it is intended to be because the beer 
already has citrus notes and the lemon would only destroy the foam.
What I see as important in mixed drinks is the idea that mixing, if done 
correctly, changes the flavour profile of some of the ingredients. I do not 
believe that the main expression of intrinsic flavour (extrinsic would be 
something like marketing effects) can be much improved in any another sense 
than only adding a different flavour to the product range (Different but not 
really better. If it would be better than it would have been bottled like 
that.). However changing the flavour profile does not necessarily need to do 
much damage to the original artwork of the brewer and leave the main artistic 
expression of flavour intact. A flavour profile can be adjusted while still 
leaving the aroma composition largely intact.
Flavour profile is what I would define as the type of combination of amount of 
astringency, amount of softness and amount of flavour intensity. These three 
components are popularly used in a model in which the three components create 
a three dimensional space in which each component is an axis. Every product or 
dish can be positioned somewhere in this space. It could also be seen as a 
cube in which each component is an axis. Each corner of the cube represents a 
different combination the three components. E.g. ice cream (corner A): low 
astringency, high softness, low intensity. Chocolate mousse (corner B): low 
astringency, high softness, high intensity. Coca Cola (corner C): high 
astringency (acid), high softness (sugar), low intensity.

               **************************
              **                       **
             * *                      * *
            *  *                     *  *
           *   *                    *   *
          *    *                   *    *
         *     *                  *     *
        ***********t************** (B)  *
        i      *  n              *      *
        n      * e               *      *
        t      *g                *      *
        e      n************************* (C)
        n     i                  *     *
        s    r                   *    *
        i   t                    *   *
        t  s                     *  *
        y a                      * *
        **                       **
        *******softness*********** (A)
            
http://www.google.com/search?q='flavour+profile'+klosse           

It can be important to change the flavour profile of a product/ingredient as 
the flavour profile interacts with our flavour perception and appreciation in 
a social-psychological way. For instance: People have different needs and 
associated with it are preferences for different flavour profiles. People who 
like to distress and relax prefer sweeter stuff. People who like to be active 
prefer a combination of high astringent and high softness.
Making a mixed drink is a way to turn the flavour profile of a certain product 
into a different one. If people like whisky flavour but don't feel for a 
strong intense flavour and high astringency, than it can be made sweeter with 
sugar and weaker with water. As such it becomes a drink which people like 
better when they need to relax, e.g. at the end of a diner. When people like 
whisky but are in need to be active and to be on the dance floor. Whisky can 
be combined with lemon juice and sugar in order to increase the astringency 
and sweetness in order to make it a drink which is prefered by people who 
have, at that time, the need to be active. In both these two examples the 
whisky is still whisky. It is not altered much by ingredients like flavoured 
liqueurs. I believe these are good drinks. The use of liqueurs and other 
flavours, however, can still be a good thing. As long as it fits the profile. 
E.g. when making a drink more soft and sweet, one could think of adding 
vanilla or almond flavours.

So, when creating mixed drinks because you want to improve beer... think about 
these three parameters: astringency mouth feel (sour, bitter, spicyness, 
etc.), soft mouth feel (creamy, mouth coating, sugar etc.) and flavour 
intensity (spices, concentrated flavours, salt-umami, etc). Also note that I 
mention mouthfeel here. A flavour is more than sweet, sour, acid and bitter. 
E.g. think about making a Ramoz Beer Fizz. The egg has no flavour in the 
traditional sense but it does have a thickening effect and creates foam 
resulting in a soft flavour.

I expressed above that an ingredients intrinsic flavour can not be much 
improved by blending partly because if it would be better it would be bottled 
and sold like that (an unmixed drink/ingredient should already be very good on 
its own). The exception is a fresh ingredient which can not be easily bottled. 
Everything which is bottled lacks the characteristic of fresh products. As 
people are often trained (or genetically programmed) to like fresh products, 
mixed drinks with fresh ingredients could (not will) be better. This point 
of view may give another lead to the creation of good mixed drinks with beer. 
Note that it is not just about adding fresh ingredients. It really should be 
something which the beer is missing and which the fresh ingredient could 
improve. And also the freshness should be of a quality which is to be liked 
because people like that certain freshness. Not all freshness is liked (e.g. 
some things need to ripen) and not all freshness is in place (would fresh 
ginger improve beer better than processed ginger?).

-- 
"Question everything..."


 Current thread (2 messages):
 Message options:
 

Gain quick access to The Webtender from your homepage.
Get HTML code here!

Home · Drink Recipes · Bookstore · Barstore · Handbook · Web Index · Feedback

Copyright © The Webtender.
About | Disclaimer | Privacy policy